I have been seeing so many posts about how Steve Rogers aka Captain America would support ICE and these "Americans" that make these claims have no clue what Captain America stands for.
Let’s be clear about one thing up front: Captain America has always been political. He was born political. He debuted in 1941 punching fascism in the face before the U.S. government even entered World War II. Pretending he’d suddenly shrug at state abuse because it’s wrapped in a flag is ahistorical nonsense.
What Captain America Actually Represents
Steve Rogers isn’t a symbol of authority. He’s a symbol of principle.
-
He stands for civil liberties
-
He defends the powerless
-
He distrusts unchecked government power
-
He walks away when institutions betray their own ideals
This is the same character who:
-
Turned against the U.S. government during Secret Empire (1974) over illegal surveillance and repression
-
Resigned the mantle rather than become a tool of the state
-
Opposed internment, profiling, and collective punishment whenever Marvel bothered to engage honestly with history
Captain America’s loyalty is to people, not badges.
ICE vs. Cap’s Moral Compass
Modern immigration enforcement tactics—family separation, indefinite detention, militarized raids, lack of due process—are exactly the kind of institutional cruelty Cap has always opposed in-story.
This isn’t about borders. It’s about how power is used.
Captain America has never supported:
-
Criminalizing existence
-
Punishing children to deter adults
-
Bureaucratic violence carried out “because it’s the law”
That “just following orders” logic? That’s the villain speech in Captain America comics. Every time.
“But He’s Patriotic!”
Yes—and that’s the point people miss on purpose.
Captain America’s patriotism is aspirational, not authoritarian.
He represents what America claims to be, not what it does when no one’s watching.
That’s why he punches Nazis.
That’s why he exposes corrupt agencies.
That’s why he sides with refugees, dissidents, and the persecuted.
If your version of Captain America is pro–mass detention, pro–collective punishment, and pro–fear-based enforcement, you didn’t read the comics—you skimmed the covers.
The Historical Irony
Captain America Comics #1 didn’t ask for permission.
It didn’t wait for public approval.
It didn’t say “both sides have a point.”
It took a stance against authoritarian cruelty before it was safe to do so.
Trying to retrofit Captain America into a mascot for harsh enforcement policies is revisionism—plain and simple.
Final Word
Captain America wouldn’t stand with ICE.
He’d be standing between ICE and the people being abused by it.
And he’d still be holding the shield.
If that makes anyone uncomfortable, good.
Captain America was never meant to be comfortable—he was meant to be right.
🛡️
No comments:
Post a Comment