Every time someone says “keep politics out of comic books,” what they really mean is:
“Keep politics I don’t like out of comic books.”
Because comics were never apolitical. Not at the mainstream level, not at the underground level, not at the indie level. From the start, comics were built to reflect real-world power, fear, propaganda, identity, war, crime, corruption, class, and culture. That’s politics.
Here’s the breakdown — comprehensively.
1) The Medium Was Born in the Shadow of Real Politics
Early superhero comics didn’t emerge in a vacuum. They emerged during:
-
the Great Depression
-
the rise of fascism in Europe
-
World War II
-
labor unrest and class anxiety
Even when a story didn’t name a political party, it dealt in political themes: who has power, who abuses it, who gets protected, and who gets sacrificed.
2) Captain America Punching Hitler Wasn’t Subtle — and It Was the Point
You don’t get to claim comics “used to be non-political” when one of the most famous covers in history is literally Captain America punching Hitler (published before the U.S. even entered WWII).
That wasn’t “just entertainment.”
That was a statement — moral, cultural, and political — printed on purpose and sold by the millions.
And it wasn’t alone. Wartime comics were packed with:
-
propaganda
-
enlistment messaging
-
enemy caricatures
-
patriotic symbolism
-
homefront anxieties
Like it or not: political.
3) The X-Men Are a Civil Rights Metaphor With a Costume Budget
The X-Men don’t work without politics. Their entire concept is:
-
discrimination
-
fear of the “other”
-
state violence
-
registration / surveillance
-
radicalization vs. assimilation
That’s civil rights conflict translated into superheroes. You can argue about which era did it better, but you can’t deny it’s political at the core.
Same for:
-
Black Panther (anti-colonialism, Black identity, geopolitics)
-
Green Lantern / Green Arrow (poverty, racism, corporate power)
-
Watchmen (Cold War anxiety, authoritarianism, moral rot)
These aren’t accidents. They’re the DNA.
4) “Politics” Isn’t Just Elections — It’s Power
A lot of people reduce “politics” to parties, slogans, and election cycles. But politics is broader:
Politics is:
-
who gets rights
-
who gets punished
-
who gets representation
-
who controls violence
-
who controls information
-
what society considers “normal” or “deviant”
So even “non-political” comics are political because:
-
the hero enforces a social order
-
the state is depicted as good/bad/corrupt
-
marginalized characters exist or don’t
-
the villain represents real-world fears (crime, drugs, war, terrorism, disease, immigration, tech)
If your story has law, authority, inequality, nationalism, religion, gender roles, corporations, war, policing, prisons, borders, or propaganda — it’s political.
That’s most comics.
5) The “Stop Putting Politics in Comics” Crowd Usually Only Notices When the Default Changes
For decades, the “default” in mainstream comics was:
-
straight
-
male
-
white
-
American-centric
-
pro-status quo heroics
That default felt “neutral” to many readers because it matched what they were used to.
So when comics expand and reflect society more honestly, some readers mistake that change for “politics being added.”
But the politics were always there — they were just invisible to people who benefited from the default.
6) Bad Writing Isn’t “Too Political” — It’s Just Bad Writing
This is the important distinction collectors and readers should be making.
Sometimes people say “politics ruined comics” when what they actually mean is:
-
preachy dialogue
-
shallow characters
-
lazy messaging
-
story taking a backseat to a lecture
That’s not a “politics problem.”
That’s a craft problem.
Good creators can write political themes with:
-
nuance
-
character-driven stakes
-
believable conflict
-
emotional truth
Bad creators can turn anything into a pamphlet — even a “non-political” power fantasy.
7) Complaining Is Pointless Because It Fights the Medium’s Nature
Comics are a pop-culture mirror. They always have been.
They adapt to:
-
wars
-
economic fear
-
social change
-
generational tension
-
new moral panics
-
new hopes
Trying to remove politics from comics is like trying to remove:
-
tragedy from Shakespeare
-
protest from punk music
-
religion from medieval art
-
capitalism from cyberpunk
You can do it technically, but you’ll kill what makes the art form alive.
8) The Real Conversation That Matters
If someone wants to talk comics seriously, the useful questions are:
✅ Is the story well-written?
✅ Do the characters feel real?
✅ Are themes earned through plot and consequence?
✅ Is the message integrated rather than stapled on?
✅ Does it respect the reader’s intelligence?
Those are valid critiques.
“Stop putting politics in comics” isn’t critique.
It’s a tantrum.
Final Word
Comics have always been political because comics have always been about people — and people live inside power structures.
So no: politics didn’t “invade” comics.
Comics were born in it.
The only thing that changes is whose politics you notice — and whose you ignore.
#Comics #ComicHistory #XMen #CaptainAmerica #ComicsArePolitical #MediaLiteracy #ComicCollecting
No comments:
Post a Comment